-

Attorney Amy Witherite Says: The Supreme Court’s Unanimous Ruling Preserves Texas Families’ Day in Court

DALLAS--(BUSINESS WIRE)--On June 28, 2025, a fatigued truck driver fell asleep at the wheel on Interstate 20 near Terrell, Texas, and plowed into stopped traffic at highway speed without ever touching his brakes. Five people died, including a daughter, a son-in-law, a grandson, and a young mother. A fourth family member survived with serious injuries. Today, the United States Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the families they left behind have the right to hold the logistics company that played a role in putting that driver on the road accountable in court. The 9-0 decision in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, written by Justice Amy Coney Barrett, held that federal law does not shield freight brokers from state-level negligent hiring lawsuits, preserving one of the most meaningful tools Texas families have when the system fails them.

That day, Anthony Epperson lost his daughter, his son-in-law, and his grandson in a catastrophic crash. His granddaughter survived with serious injuries. Nicole LaJeunesse Gregory, a mother, daughter, and sister, was also killed. A fatigued truck driver hauling U.S. Postal Service mail fell asleep at the wheel and plowed into stopped traffic at highway speed without ever touching his brakes. He now faces criminal charges, including manslaughter. The driver worked for Hope Trans LLC, a company that had at least 12 reportable crashes since 2021, a vehicle out-of-service rate nearly three times the industry average, and a pattern of falsified driver logs, all publicly visible in a federal database. A large logistics company had accepted the USPS contract and subcontracted the load to Hope Trans and is being sued for its role in assigning the load to Hope Trans.

“This decision recognizes the fact that a broker selected Hope Trans for the load despite the company’s bad record,” said Amy Witherite, founder of Witherite Law Group, which represents the Epperson and LaJeunesse families. “Brokers are a key link in the transportation chain, and the Court agreed that they share responsibility for avoiding fly-by-night trucking companies with questionable safety records. These companies often carry minimal insurance and hold limited assets, leaving families with catastrophic losses and nowhere to turn when an 80,000-pound truck collides with a passenger car.”

“It is important to be clear about what is not at stake in this Supreme Court decision,” said Witherite. “This is not a choice between federal regulation and state accountability; it is a false choice the industry wanted you to accept, and the Court unanimously rejected it.”

According to the National Safety Council, 5,340 people died in large-truck crashes in 2024, a 30% increase over the last decade, with 70% of those deaths being occupants of other vehicles, not truck drivers. Strong, well-funded, and rigorously enforced federal safety standards are essential. Nobody disputes that. But strong federal regulation and the right of innocent victims to seek full compensation in court are not substitutes for each other. One does not replace the other. Telling a grieving family that federal rules were supposed to protect them even when those rules demonstrably failed is not justice. It is an excuse. The right to hold negligent parties accountable in court does not undermine federal oversight. It complements it.

“Today’s Supreme Court ruling is a victory for the Epperson and LaJeunesse families and for every American family that deserves what they asked for: the right to go to court, present the evidence, and let a jury decide who bears responsibility for a preventable tragedy,” said Witherite. “The Court held unanimously that states retain authority to hold logistics companies accountable for negligent hiring decisions and that no federal shield protects brokers who ignore carrier safety records.”

“That ruling matters. But it is not the end of the work. We still need stronger federal enforcement, an end to the chameleon carrier loophole, and courts that remain open to families the system has already failed. Those goals are not in conflict with each other or with what the Court decided today. They are part of the same obligation.”

Contacts

The Margulies Communications Group
mediainquiries@prexperts.net
214-368-0909

Witherite Law Group


Release Versions

Contacts

The Margulies Communications Group
mediainquiries@prexperts.net
214-368-0909

More News From Witherite Law Group

Witherite Law Group Founder Amy Witherite Calls for Federal Driverless Taxi Safety Standards

DALLAS--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Amy Witherite, founder of Witherite Law Group and a traffic safety advocate, is calling for federal standards requiring driverless taxi operators to show they can quickly clear vehicles from the path of first responders before putting them on public roads. In Dallas, a deputy constable spent about three minutes trying to move a Waymo that obstructed the response to a deadly apartment explosion and fire. He eventually moved it using the steering wheel, a feature some rob...

Witherite Law Group Founder Amy Witherite: “First Responders Shouldn’t Have to Beg a Robot to Move” as Bill to Clear Robotaxis From Emergency Scenes Stalls in Congress

DALLAS--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Amy Witherite, founder of Witherite Law Group and a traffic safety expert, is raising concerns about a federal bill that would require driverless cars to move out of the way of police, firefighters and other first responders. The legislation has stalled in Congress without a single cosponsor, even as Waymo moves toward a planned 20,000-vehicle robotaxi fleet and tests its vehicles on Philadelphia streets. “Every week more of these cars hit the road, and Congress still h...

Promise vs. Performance: Founder of Witherite Law Group Amy Witherite Says Three Years of Austin Robotaxi Data Show What Your City Can Expect

DALLAS--(BUSINESS WIRE)--As driverless cars roll into more American cities, the city with the longest public record of what goes wrong offers a preview. Between July 2023 and September 2026, the City of Austin logged more than 320 incidents involving driverless vehicles. Traffic safety advocate Amy Witherite, founder of Witherite Law Group, says that record shows the technology is not ready and is calling on regulators and autonomous vehicle manufacturers to demonstrate that these vehicles can...
Back to Newsroom