Michelle Stoughton Named President of Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield Medicaid in Ohio

Seasoned healthcare policy and government executive to lead plan serving more than 200,000 Ohioans

COLUMBUS, Ohio--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield (Anthem), a leading provider of health benefits for Ohio residents enrolled in the state’s Medicaid managed care program, announced today that Michelle Stoughton has been named president of its Medicaid health plan.

“Michelle is a highly respected leader with extensive experience in healthcare policy and government,” said Jennie Reynolds, east region president of Anthem Medicaid. “Her proven track record in Ohio and her dedication to community health make her exceptionally well-suited to lead our Medicaid operations in the state. We are confident in Michelle’s ability to drive innovation, foster strong partnerships, and improve the whole health of the Ohioans we serve.”

In her new role, Stoughton assumes responsibility for all aspects of Anthem’s Medicaid health plan operations in Ohio, ensuring its more than 200,000 members receive access to innovative, high-quality healthcare and support services. She will also lead efforts to strengthen relationships in the community with state leaders, providers, and other key stakeholders. Starting in 2026, Anthem will be one of four managed care organizations to provide services to Ohioans who are dually eligible for both Medicare and Medicaid healthcare coverage under its Next Generation MyCare Ohio program, in addition to continuing to provide benefits through the managed care program.

“Anthem’s long-standing commitment to improving the health of Ohio communities is one I deeply share, and I’m honored to take on this leadership role,” said Stoughton. “I look forward to working alongside our state partners, providers, members, and local organizations to strengthen access to high-quality care—both today and as we prepare to support some of Ohio’s most vulnerable individuals in the Next Generation MyCare Ohio program beginning in 2026. Together, we’ll continue to serve with compassion, elevate health outcomes, and make a meaningful impact in the lives of Ohioans across the state.”

Stoughton brings nearly 15 years of experience in healthcare policy to her new role. She most recently served as the regional vice president of government relations for Anthem in Ohio and managed the central region team of senior government relations directors for Anthem’s parent company. Before that, Stoughton served as the Midwest director for Albers & Company and as government relations director for the Ohio Council of Retail Merchants. She has also served as a legislative aide in the Ohio House of Representatives. Stoughton holds a bachelor’s degree from Miami University and a Master of Public Administration from The Ohio State University. She volunteers as coordinator of All Saints Episcopal Church’s In the Garden Program, a meal service for homeless individuals in downtown Columbus.

About Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Ohio

Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield is the trade name of Community Insurance Company, an independent licensee of the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association. ANTHEM is a registered trademark of Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc. The Blue Cross and Blue Shield names and symbols are registered marks of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association. Additional information about Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Ohio is available at www.anthem.com. Also, follow us on LinkedIn, Facebook, and X at @AnthemBCBS.