-

Methuselah Advisors Issues Open Letter to the Board of Directors of NVIDIA Corporation

NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Methuselah Advisors today issued the following open letter:

To: Harvey C. Jones, Chairman, and the Board of Directors of NVIDIA Corporation

Re: The Removal of Jensen Huang — Fiduciary Responsibility, Shareholder Value, and the Imperative of Due Process

Dear Chairman Jones and Members of the Board:

The decision to separate Jensen Huang from NVIDIA, the company he founded and led for more than three decades represents, in our judgment, an extraordinary failure of corporate stewardship. It raises serious questions about whether NVIDIA’s Board of Directors has adequately discharged its fiduciary responsibilities to shareholders or has instead subordinated their economic interests to considerations of personal conduct, reputational sensitivity, and corporate virtue signaling.

The consequences have been staggering. NVIDIA has experienced a decline approaching 36% of its market capitalization during the controversy, representing more than $1.4 trillion dollars in lost shareholder value. While market movements reflect multiple influences, there can be little question that the abrupt displacement of the executive most closely identified with NVIDIA’s extraordinary success has introduced substantial uncertainty into the company’s future.

The Board has a responsibility to explain why such a consequential action was necessary before its own investigation had reached a publicly disclosed conclusion.

Let us begin with what is known.

Jensen Huang has acknowledged personal conduct that has become the subject of widespread public criticism. Reports of extramarital relationships, including one involving an individual suspected of connections to Chinese intelligence, understandably warrant careful review and scrutiny. Allegations involving relationships with company employees likewise merit examination under NVIDIA’s policies and established standards of corporate governance. Consenting adults or not, companies have HR policies and they apply all the way to the top.

We do not suggest that any chief executive, irrespective of accomplishment, should be exempt from accountability. Nor should national-security concerns, potential conflicts of interest, or violations of applicable law ever be minimized.

But there is a profound difference between conduct that warrants independent investigation and confirmed findings that justify the permanent removal of an extraordinarily successful chief executive.

Personal infidelity is not, by itself, evidence of corporate misconduct, a breach of fiduciary responsibility, or an inability to lead a public enterprise.

The relevant questions are whether Huang knowingly facilitated any unlawful transfer of NVIDIA technology, compromised proprietary information, violated applicable export restrictions, abused his corporate authority, or otherwise engaged in conduct materially detrimental to the company and its shareholders.

These questions demand a thorough, independent, evidence-based investigation. They cannot responsibly be answered through public speculation, moral condemnation, or an understandable desire to distance the corporation from an embarrassing controversy.

Indeed, on November 8, NVIDIA’s own Board publicly stated that it had no reason to believe that national security or company secrets had been compromised. It simultaneously expressed confidence in Huang and his leadership team.

Within days, that confidence had apparently evaporated.

What changed?

What evidence emerged between those statements and Huang’s departure that justified removing the individual most responsible for NVIDIA’s strategic leadership, technological dominance, commercial relationships, and extraordinary creation of shareholder wealth?

The Board has not adequately answered that question publicly.

Even more troubling is its subsequent declaration that Huang will not be reinstated as chief executive, notwithstanding the continuing investigation.

How can the Board have reached an apparently irrevocable judgment when the investigation intended to establish the underlying facts remains incomplete?

Corporate directors are not appointed to serve as arbiters of personal morality. They are entrusted with protecting the enterprise, exercising independent judgment, evaluating risk, complying with applicable law, and preserving and enhancing long-term shareholder value.

That responsibility necessarily encompasses appropriate standards of executive behavior. But it also requires proportionality, procedural rigor, and an understanding of the economic consequences of every major corporate decision.

NVIDIA is not an ordinary enterprise, and Jensen Huang is not an interchangeable executive.

Under his leadership, NVIDIA evolved from a graphics-chip company into the central technological infrastructure provider of the artificial-intelligence revolution. Its commercial architecture, developer ecosystem, strategic customer relationships, and leadership in accelerated computing are inseparable from the vision and execution he provided over more than three decades.

The company’s latest quarterly financial performance reinforces the magnitude of that achievement: revenue of $115.8 billion, an increase of 103% from the comparable period one year earlier.

Replacing the architect of that success is not analogous to replacing an executive in an established business operating within a mature and predictable industry.

It introduces consequential risks to strategy, innovation, customer relationships, employee confidence, geopolitical negotiations, and competitive positioning during one of the most important technological transitions in modern history. These risks must be weighed against the actual, demonstrable risks associated with Huang’s continued participation in the enterprise.

We are particularly troubled by the possibility that the Board has effectively substituted the appearance of moral rectitude for a considered economic and legal analysis of its responsibilities.

Corporate governance cannot become a contest in reputational purification, in which allegations of personal misconduct automatically outweigh decades of exceptional performance without a disciplined examination of their relevance to the business.

Shareholders are entitled to more. The massive destruction of value demands it. And there is a practical and responsible alternative.

We urge the Board to invite Jensen Huang to return immediately as Executive Chairman, pending completion of its independent investigation.

Under such an arrangement, he could continue providing strategic leadership, technical vision, continuity in key commercial relationships, and institutional knowledge, while Colette Kress and the existing management team retain responsibility for day-to-day operations.

The Board should with counsel establish clear and independently enforced safeguards, including appropriate restrictions on Huang’s involvement in any matter implicated by the investigation, relevant export-control decisions, and relationships that might create conflicts of interest.

The independent committee and its outside counsel must retain complete authority to investigate without interference. Any return to an executive position must also be consistent with applicable legal, regulatory, and national-security requirements.

This structure would allow NVIDIA to preserve the value of its founder’s leadership without compromising the integrity of the investigation.

At its conclusion, the Board should make a fully informed determination, grounded in verified evidence, as to whether Huang should resume the position of Chief Executive Officer, continue in another appropriate executive capacity, or permanently leave the company.

If material wrongdoing is established, appropriate action should follow. But if the investigation produces no substantiated finding of serious corporate misconduct, the Board should be prepared to restore Huang’s leadership rather than allow an extraordinary corporate achievement to be diminished by an exercise in reputational expediency.

We recognize that the Board may possess material nonpublic information that cannot presently be disclosed. If so, it must act consistently with its legal obligations and the integrity of the investigation. Nevertheless, shareholders deserve an explanation of the process employed, the alternatives considered, and the reasons an interim leadership arrangement involving Huang was rejected.

The Board should also explain how it assessed the enormous economic consequences of permanently severing NVIDIA’s relationship with its founder, particularly when the company was continuing to deliver exceptional financial and operating results.

It is not sufficient merely to express confidence in a successor management team or gratitude for Huang’s past contributions.

The obligation is to demonstrate that the decision to remove him permanently represents the best available course for the enterprise and its owners.

Fiduciary responsibility is not discharged by demonstrating moral disapproval. It is discharged by exercising informed, independent, proportionate judgment in the long-term interests of the corporation and its shareholders.

The Board’s handling of this episode has raised serious doubts about whether that standard has been met.

We therefore urge you to reconsider the decision not to reinstate Huang, establish a carefully controlled interim Executive Chairman arrangement, complete the independent investigation with dispatch, and defer any permanent determination concerning his future until the relevant facts are established.

NVIDIA’s shareholders should not be required to bear the potentially permanent economic consequences of a judgment that may have been rendered before the evidence was in.

There is still an opportunity for the Board to demonstrate sound judgment, restore confidence, and distinguish legitimate corporate accountability from unnecessary destruction of shareholder value.

We urge you to seize it.

Respectfully,

John Chachas
Co-Managing Partner
Methuselah Advisors

Contacts

Methuselah Advisors
212.750.0920

Methuselah Advisors


Release Versions

Contacts

Methuselah Advisors
212.750.0920

Back to Newsroom