-

Cronyism Crushes Inclusion Yet Again in Latest Chancery Court Appointment

Diversity Sent to Back of the Bus Once More as Connected Skadden Insider Named to Powerful Post

WILMINGTON, Del.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--The appointment this week of Bonnie David as master in chancery at the Delaware Court of Chancery exposed once more the lack of commitment to representation on one of the most important and powerful courts in the state and the nation -- and drew fierce fire from civil rights leaders who blasted the blatant disregard for diversity.

"The addition of yet another plugged-in white Skadden attorney to the Delaware judiciary -- particularly one with as much national reach and impact as the Chancery -- makes a mockery of the values of inclusion and equal opportunity. There are country clubs with more diversity than this powerful court," said civil rights icon Reverend Al Sharpton. "That's an outrage anywhere -- but it's particularly offensive in a state where 30% of the people are nonwhite. It's long past time to break the stranglehold of the elite and powerful on the institutions of justice, and add more legal leaders of color to the bench."

"The Chancery Court is as large as it's ever been, yet remains -- like the entire Delaware judiciary -- overwhelmingly white. This isn't just a missed opportunity to build a fair court system -- it's the continuation of an entrenched system where the rich and powerful law firms like Skadden amass and wield judicial power. Everyone else is shut out of the process, with their noses pressed against the window as key decisions that affect the lives of all Delarareans every single day are handed down imperiously," said prominent Wilmington advocate Keandra McDole. "It's a slap in the face."

The pointed controversy over the David appointment comes on the heels of intense public pressure on Delaware Gov. John Carney to make diverse appointments to two current openings on the state Supreme Court. The recent elevation of Delaware's lone Black justice Tamika Montgomery-Reeves to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals once again leaves Delaware's top two courts without a justice of color.

Citizens for Judicial Fairness


Release Versions

More News From Citizens for Judicial Fairness

Statement from Citizens for Judicial Fairness on the Retirement of Justice Karen L. Valihura

WILMINGTON, Del.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Citizens for Judicial Fairness recognizes the announced retirement of Justice Karen L. Valihura as a significant moment for Delaware’s judiciary. Justice Valihura earned widespread respect for her principled commitment to statutory interpretation, judicial restraint, and respect for the limits of judicial authority. Throughout her tenure, she emphasized that courts must apply the law as written and avoid substituting judicial judgment for lawful business and s...

Citizens for Judicial Fairness Slams Outrageous Attorney Fees Awarded in Delaware Following Comprehensive New Study

WILMINGTON, Del.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Today, Citizens for Judicial Fairness condemned the Delaware Court of Chancery’s outrageous attorney fee rewards following a new academic study that exposes how fees are spiraling out of control and disconnected from any meaningful measure of risk or performance. The study from three law school professors reveals that Chancery fee awards lack consistent benchmarks and routinely overreward a small group of insider law firms, including cases where judges approve...

Citizens for Judicial Fairness Celebrates Introduction of Wheelspin in Delaware’s Chancery Court, a Historic Win for Chancery Reform Advocates

WILMINGTON, Del.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Today, following the announcement that Delaware’s Court of Chancery will introduce randomized, automated case assignments – or “wheelspin” – effective September 15, 2015, Citizens for Judicial Fairness released the following statement from TransPerfect Founder Phil Shawe “For over a decade, TransPerfect has fought for basic fairness in the Chancery Court. Adopting a randomized “wheelspin” method to decide what judge is assigned to a case--and taking that power...
Back to Newsroom