-

A tale of two countries offers lessons for Ontario: new academic reports show Scotland’s public hospitals outperformed England’s privatization scheme to deliver surgeries

The academic reports on hip, knee, and cataract surgeries will be released at a press conference at Queen’s Park on Monday morning

TORONTO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--In the early 2000s, the Labour government in England began contracting out hospital surgeries to for-profit facilities with the stated policy objective of reducing wait-times. Currently, the private sector is the main provider of hip, knee and cataract surgeries in the country.

During the same period, the Scotland government took a different approach: it brought a private hospital under public ownership in 2003 as it prioritized public provision of health care services with minimal contracting out.

Two new academic reports co-authored by Professor Allyson Pollock, illustrate the benefits of the Scottish approach, which made more efficient use of tax dollars and provided care on an egalitarian basis that prioritized people’s needs over their affluence. In England, privatization benefitted the wealthy while the majority suffered as resources were drained from the public system.

These reports offer lessons for Ontario, which is comparatively in the initial stages of its hospital privatization plan and has used the same rationale to contract out cataract, hip, and knee surgeries.

On Monday, Pollock will be joined at Queen’s Park by OCHU-CUPE president Michael Hurley and Ontario Health Coalition executive director to reveal detailed findings of these academic studies and offer lessons for Ontario.

Who:
Allyson Pollock, professor emerita at Newcastle University
Natalie Mehra, executive director of the Ontario Health Coalition
Michael Hurley, president of OCHU-CUPE

What:
Media conference to release new reports on hospital privatization in England and Scotland

Where:
Queen’s Park media studio, Toronto

When:
10 a.m. on Monday, November 10

:gv/cope491

Contacts

For more information, contact:
Zee Noorsumar
CUPE Communications
znoorsumar@cupe.ca
647-995-9859

Industry:

Canadian Union of Public Employees

Release Versions
English

Contacts

For more information, contact:
Zee Noorsumar
CUPE Communications
znoorsumar@cupe.ca
647-995-9859

More News From Canadian Union of Public Employees

Unionbusting and safety concerns continue at Rockcliffe Flying Club as CIRB delays certification

Ottawa, ON--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Workers at the Rockcliffe Flying Club filed to join CUPE in December 2025 after raising concerns about workplace culture and aircraft safety. Instead of respecting those concerns and letting workers exercise their right to join a union, the employer has responded with delay, pressure, and retaliation. What should have been the straightforward certification process is still not finished, nearly four months later. In that time, workers say the employer has used the de...

TCDSB Ends Beloved Language Program After 50 Years, 77 Jobs Lost

TORONTO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--On Thursday the Toronto Catholic District School Board announced that they will completely eliminate its long-standing International Languages Program, resulting in 77 dedicated language instructors losing their jobs. “This is a devastating and short-sighted decision,” said Val Di Gregorio, President of CUPE 3155, representing the language instructors. “For decades, this program has enriched students’ lives, strengthened communities and supported cultural connections....

“Cold-blooded decision on hospital funding,” says CUPE in response to Ford government’s 2026 budget

TORONTO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--The real dollar hospital funding cut announced in the 2026 provincial budget will intensify the crisis in Ontario’s hospitals, which are already funded at the lowest rate in the country, says the Canadian Union of Public Employees. “The government increased hospital funding by four per cent - a real cut of two per cent when measured against the six per cent increase in costs related to an ageing and growing population. This funding shortfall compounds a two per cent cu...
Back to Newsroom