AM Best Downgrades Credit Ratings of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company

OLDWICK, N.J.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--AM Best has downgraded the Financial Strength Rating (FSR) to B++ (Good) from A- (Excellent) and the Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating (Long-Term ICR) to “bbb+” (Good) from “a-” (Excellent) of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company (Brotherhood) (Fort Wayne, IN). The outlook of the FSR has been revised to stable from negative while the outlook of the Long-Term ICR is negative.

The Credit Ratings (ratings) reflect Brotherhood’s balance sheet strength, which AM Best assesses as strong, as well as its adequate operating performance, neutral business profile and appropriate enterprise risk management (ERM).

The ratings downgrade reflects erosion in the company’s surplus position and correlating risk-adjusted capitalization, as measured by Best’s Capital Adequacy Ratio (BCAR), elevated leverage metrics, and volatility in its commercial multi-peril, liability and commercial auto reserve development. Erosion in Brotherhood’s capital was primarily driven by a progressive deterioration in underwriting earnings. The company’s underwriting performance has been challenged by elevated weather-related losses, particularly multiple low level catastrophe losses impacting its property insurance book. Management recently introduced wind and hail deductibles in coastal areas, rate increases, a quota share and tighter underwriting guidelines to improve results.

The negative outlook on the Long-Term ICR reflects ongoing pressure on the operating performance assessment given elevated volatility in results, along with continued pressure on the balance sheet strength assessment associated with unfavorable trends in risk-adjusted capitalization and elevated leverage metrics. While overall reserves were in a redundant position as of year-end 2023, overall favorable development is attributed to large releases in the worker’s compensation line of business offsetting deficiencies in liability, CMP and commercial auto lines. The company is a market leader within its niche with a strong presence in the congregational and hierarchical church markets, distributing through a well-established network. ERM is assessed as appropriate, focusing on risk mitigation and control, aided by a comprehensive reinsurance program.

This press release relates to Credit Ratings that have been published on AM Best’s website. For all rating information relating to the release and pertinent disclosures, including details of the office responsible for issuing each of the individual ratings referenced in this release, please see AM Best’s Recent Rating Activity web page. For additional information regarding the use and limitations of Credit Rating opinions, please view Guide to Best's Credit Ratings. For information on the proper use of Best’s Credit Ratings, Best’s Performance Assessments, Best’s Preliminary Credit Assessments and AM Best press releases, please view Guide to Proper Use of Best’s Ratings & Assessments.

AM Best is a global credit rating agency, news publisher and data analytics provider specializing in the insurance industry. Headquartered in the United States, the company does business in over 100 countries with regional offices in London, Amsterdam, Dubai, Hong Kong, Singapore and Mexico City. For more information, visit www.ambest.com.

Copyright © 2024 by A.M. Best Rating Services, Inc. and/or its affiliates. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.