Study Suggests Women CEOs Face a ‘Green Ceiling’ in Attracting IPO Investors

  • Women Have Made Huge Strides in Executive Ranks, but IPOs Still Appear to be a Man’s Game
  • Research Suggests that a Lack of Female-led IPOs Reveals a Gender-Based Capital Gap
  • Bias Seems to Rule Regardless of Female CEO Experience, Qualifications and a Firm’s Financial Health

SALT LAKE CITY--()--When it comes to a company’s critical stock market debut, investors are less likely to trust their money to an enterprise led by a female CEO, a University of Utah researcher says.

“Bias against top-level female executives seems entrenched despite strides women have made in filling management positions within firms making their initial public offerings (IPOs),” says Lyda Bigelow, assistant professor at the university’s David Eccles School of Business.

The paper has been accepted for publication in a future edition of the Journal of Management. “Skirting the Issues: Evidence of Gender Bias in IPO Prospectus Evaluations,” authored by Bigelow, (along with co-authors Robert Wuebker, a post-doctoral fellow at the David Eccles School; Leif Lundmark, a doctoral candidate at the David Eccles School; and Judi McLean Parks, a professor of Organizational Behavior at Washington University’s Olin Business School), concluded that the “lack of female-led IPOs suggests a potentially larger problem – a gender-based capital gap for new ventures.”

In 2009, for example, not one of the 19 high-tech IPOs the researchers studied was led by a female CEO, although all but two of those firms had one or more lower-ranking female executives. The study points out an apparent reluctance to invest in IPOs spearheaded by women even though nearly half of all privately held businesses in the United States today are owned, or led by women. Statistics also indicate that between 1997 and 2007, women holding corporate officer positions grew from 10 percent to 55 percent.

In their research, Bigelow and her colleagues found that, “Despite identical personal qualifications and firm financials, female founders/CEOs were perceived as less capable than their male counterparts, and IPOs led by female founders/CEOs were considered less attractive investments.”

The study enlisted 222 second-year MBA candidates – 45 of them females – a sampling the researchers say were not far removed in their experience levels of the junior staffers usually assigned to assess real IPOs for investors. As part of their study on IPOs, the students created a fictitious cosmetic surgery firm that was modeled using financial data from a real company’s successful entry into the stock market.

Keeping the IPO’s financial and industry information identical, the researchers only varied the gender distribution of the bogus company’s top management team. For example, first names were changed from Matthew to Martha Evans, along with associated executive photos in the IPO pitch materials the students reviewed.

“Like the glass ceiling of corporate America that has limited the advancement of female managers, female entrepreneurs face a ‘green ceiling’ when it comes to financing,” wrote the researchers. “Taken as a whole, our results suggest that gender stereotypes are alive and well and, moreover, that such stereotypes impact investment decisions...”

The research paper can be downloaded and read in its entirety by visiting http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1556449.

About the David Eccles School of Business

Founded in 1917 in Salt Lake City, the David Eccles School of Business has programs in entrepreneurship, technology innovation and venture capital management. Emphasizing interdisciplinary education and experiential learning, it launched the country’s largest student-run venture capital fund with $18.3 million, and is home to the Pierre Lassonde Entrepreneur Center and the Sorenson Center for Discovery and Innovation. Approximately 3,500 students are enrolled in its undergraduate, graduate and executive degree programs as well as joint MBA programs in architecture, law and health administration. For more information, visit www.business.utah.edu.

Contacts

David Eccles School of Business
Chris Treasure, 801-587-9456
chris.treasure@utah.edu
or
Method Communications
Alex Koritz, 801-461-9795
alex@methodcommunications.com

Release Summary

New Study Suggests Lack of Female-led IPOs Reveals Gender-Based Gap

Contacts

David Eccles School of Business
Chris Treasure, 801-587-9456
chris.treasure@utah.edu
or
Method Communications
Alex Koritz, 801-461-9795
alex@methodcommunications.com