Obamacare Coverage Would Be Unaffordable in 2018 for Most Consumers Ages 45+, eHealth Report Shows

A 10% price increase in 2018 would leave the majority of health insurance shoppers with no “affordable” health insurance options by age 45 if they don’t qualify for subsidies

MOUNTAIN VIEW, Calif.--()--The average 45-year-old who earns too much to qualify for subsidies under the Affordable Care Act (the ACA or Obamacare) would not have access to affordable health insurance in 2018, according to a new analysis published today by eHealth, Inc. (NASDAQ: EHTH), which operates eHealth.com, a leading private online health insurance marketplace.

Projecting rate increases of 10 percent across 25 cities and limiting its review to middle-income consumers who earn 401 percent of the federal poverty level (making them ineligible for subsidies), eHealth found that for this group:

  • 60-year-olds would need to earn an additional $46,658 per year before the lowest-priced plan available meets Obamacare’s affordability criteria.
  • 55-year-olds would need to earn an additional $30,262 per year before the lowest-priced plan available meets Obamacare’s affordability criteria.
  • 45-year-olds would need to earn an additional $3,400 per year before the lowest-priced plan available meets Obamacare’s affordability criteria.
  • 35- and 25-year-olds who earn too much to qualify for subsidies would generally still be able to purchase coverage that meets ACA standards for affordability.

The Affordable Care Act considers health insurance to be “unaffordable” when annual premiums for the lowest-priced plan in a market cost more than 8.16 percent of a person’s modified adjusted gross income (or MAGI). When health insurance is unaffordable by this standard, individuals and families may qualify for an exemption from Obamacare’s individual mandate to buy health insurance.

Government subsidies for monthly health insurance premiums are available to people earning up to 400 percent of the federal poverty level, but middle-income individuals who earn 401 percent or more of the federal poverty level are not eligible for this subsidy assistance.

“Obamacare simply isn’t working for middle-income and middle-aged Americans who buy health insurance on their own,” said eHealth CEO Scott Flanders. “Our data show that many people age 45 and above are being asked to pay outrageous premiums for their coverage or risk going uninsured. These are the people who are being hurt by Obamacare, and they need government reform and affordable coverage options now.”

Mr. Flanders continued: “Meanwhile, lower-income and younger folks are often able to get subsidy assistance but are denied the right to choose from Obamacare-compliant plans not offered on government sites. Younger Americans should be able to access a transparent and competitive online healthcare marketplace, like those they enjoy in almost every other area of the economy. Policymakers should lower barriers and empower all Americans – young and old – with choice and buying power.”

The table below summarizes eHealth’s findings across all surveyed cities by age group:

                     

Age of
health-
insurance
shopper

 

2017 annual
premiums
for lowest-
cost plan

 

Projected
2018
premiums
with 10%
increase over
2017

 

Affordability
threshold (annual
income at which
projected
premiums
become
"affordable")

 

Subsidy
threshold
(annual income
at which
subsidies are
no longer
available)

 

Affordability
gap
(additional
income
needed to
make
projected
premiums
"affordable")

60   $7,048.64   $7,753.51   $95,018.45   $48,360.00   $46,658.45
55   $5,832.36   $6,415.59   $78,622.44   $48,360.00   $30,262.44
45   $3,839.66   $4,223.63   $51,760.11   $48,360.00   $3,400.11
35   $3,273.74   $3,601.11   $44,131.27   $48,360.00   no gap
25   $2,420.96   $2,663.05   $32,635.47   $48,360.00   no gap
         

The following table highlights the five least affordable cities (among the 25 surveyed) for individuals age 45.

                 

City or Metro
Area

 

Projected 2018
premiums with
10% increase over
2017

 

Affordability
threshold
(annual income
at which
projected
premiums
become
"affordable")

 

Subsidy threshold
(annual income at
which subsidies are
no longer
available)

 

Affordability gap
(additional income
needed to make
projected
premiums
"affordable")

Phoenix, AZ   $6,645.14   $81,435.59   $48,360.00   $33,075.59
Raleigh, NC   $5,717.98   $70,073.24   $48,360.00   $21,713.24
Lincoln, NE   $5,717.18   $70,063.53   $48,360.00   $21,703.53

Oklahoma City,
OK

  $5,201.72   $63,746.62   $48,360.00   $15,386.62
Mobile, AL   $5,074.87   $62,192.06   $48,360.00   $13,832.06
       

More detailed findings across the 25 cities analyzed may be found here.

These figures are based on a uniform, conservative 10% projected increase in health-insurance premiums between 2017 and 2018. In fact, some independent projections for 2018 have estimated that premiums may increase 20% or more on average. There will likely be significant variability in the actual rate increase in 2018 for each plan and each market.

Methodology

eHealth surveyed 2017 premiums for the lowest-cost ACA-compliant plan available in 25 cities and/or metropolitan areas for individuals ages 25, 35, 45, 55 and 60. Rates were gathered through the federally run health insurance exchange Healthcare.gov and through the government-run health insurance marketplaces of California and New York.

Premium projections for 2018 were calculated with a 10 percent projected increase over 2017. This 10 percent projected increase was an assumption used for analysis, and is not intended to imply that all plans will uniformly increase at the same rate or to reflect the actual rate increase for any specific plan in any market or for any aggregated set of plans. Each plan in each market will have its own actual rate increase (or possibly in some cases, decrease) for 2018. Rates may vary from zip code to zip code within the same metropolitan area or state, and less-costly plans may be available in some cases to consumers who do not use the health insurance exchanges and marketplaces noted above. In addition, this analysis does not attempt to predict legislative, regulatory, or other changes that may affect the actual 2018 rates for plans.

In determining the subsidy threshold – the point at which government subsidies are no longer available to people purchasing qualifying health plans – eHealth employed federal poverty-level guidelines for 2017. Subsidies may be available to people with a household income of up to 400 percent of the federal poverty level; as such, eHealth’s described “subsidy threshold” is calculated at 401 percent of the federal poverty level for 2017. The “affordability threshold” is calculated as the annual household income level at which eHealth’s 2018 premium projections reach 8.16 percent of household income. This is the point at which the lowest-priced available plan is considered unaffordable under the rules of the Affordable Care Act for 2017.

About eHealth

eHealth, Inc. (NASDAQ: EHTH) owns eHealth.com, a leading private online health insurance exchange where individuals, families and small businesses can compare health insurance products from brand-name insurers side by side and purchase and enroll in coverage online and over the phone. eHealth offers thousands of individual, family and small business health plans underwritten by many of the nation's leading health insurance companies. eHealth (through its subsidiaries) is licensed to sell health insurance in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. eHealth also offers educational resources, exceptional telephonic support, and powerful online and pharmacy-based tools to help Medicare beneficiaries navigate Medicare health insurance options, choose the right plan and enroll in select plans online or over the phone through Medicare.com (www.Medicare.com), eHealthMedicare.com (www.eHealthMedicare.com) and PlanPrescriber.com (www.PlanPrescriber.com).

For more health insurance news and information, visit eHealth's Consumer Resource Center.

Contacts

DMA Communications for eHealth, Inc.
Sande Drew, 916-207-7674
sande.drew@ehealth.com
or
eHealth, Inc.
Nate Purpura, 650-210-3115
nate.purpura@ehealth.com

Release Summary

An eHealth report on projected 2018 health insurance costs shows that coverage may be unaffordable by ACA rules for many people age 45 and older.

Contacts

DMA Communications for eHealth, Inc.
Sande Drew, 916-207-7674
sande.drew@ehealth.com
or
eHealth, Inc.
Nate Purpura, 650-210-3115
nate.purpura@ehealth.com